Protein Pudding Cups — the high-protein banana pudding you didn’t know you needed

Protein Pudding Cups: creamy layers of banana-flavored protein custard, crunchy sugar-free vanilla wafers, and fresh banana slices — all stacked in a jar for a portable, post-workout treat or a guilt-free dessert. It’s basically banana pudding, but smarter.

Who says indulgence can’t pull double duty as protein-packed fuel? Ready to ditch the condensed-milk drama and make a no-bake pudding that actually helps your macros? Let’s go.

What makes these Protein Pudding Cups irresistible

• Texture play. Smooth, spoonable protein custard vs. slightly softened wafers vs. fresh banana — every bite surprises.
• Flavor that actually tastes like banana (thanks to banana instant pudding) without the sugar crash.
• Zero-bake, zero fuss. No ovens, no long waits — perfect among Easy Healthy Pudding Recipes.
• Use-anytime flexibility. Morning snack, dessert, or an easy grab-and-go post-workout jar.

Sound good? Also, FYI: my husband ate two straight afternoons in a row. That’s a valid endorsement.

The story behind this jar

I got curious after too many late-night cravings for banana pudding and not enough willpower for the real thing. I wanted the flavor, not the sugar — and I wanted protein. So I riffed on classic layers with Greek yogurt, a scoop of vanilla protein powder, sugar-free banana pudding mix, and gluten-free vanilla wafers. It turned out gorgeous and surprisingly satisfying. I tested it twice in two days (science), and the verdict was unanimous: do this. IMO, banana pudding just leveled up.

---

Ingredients (with quick notes)

(Makes about 4 small jars)

• 2 cups non-fat Greek yogurt — the protein-rich base; thick and creamy.
• 1–2 scoops vanilla protein powder — pick your favorite whey or plant-based option (Ascent works great). This is the sweetness source.
• 1 package sugar-free banana instant pudding mix — gives that unmistakable banana flavor without sugar.
• 1/2–3/4 cup unsweetened almond milk — thin the custard to your preferred thickness.
• Vanilla wafers (sugar-free or gluten-free) — for crunch and nostalgia.
• 2–3 ripe bananas, sliced — fresh fruit layers.
• Optional: stevia or monk fruit — if you want it sweeter.
• Optional: a dash of cinnamon or vanilla extract — for extra depth.

Why these: Greek yogurt adds tang and protein; protein powder supplies recovery fuel; pudding mix delivers banana flavor without the sugar baggage; milk controls texture; wafers add the classic crumble.

---

Quick how-to: assemble these in under 15 minutes

1. Make the protein custard. In a bowl, whisk Greek yogurt, protein powder, pudding mix, and a splash of almond milk. Add milk a little at a time until you reach a thick, pudding-like texture. Whisk vigorously to avoid lumps.
2. Prep layers. Crush a few wafers (not into dust — leave some crumbs). Slice bananas thinly.
3. Build the jars. Spoon a couple tablespoons of custard into the bottom of each jar. Add a layer of crushed wafers, then a layer of banana slices. Repeat until jars are filled, finishing with a dollop of custard and a few wafer crumbs on top.
4. Chill. Refrigerate at least 15–30 minutes so the wafers soften slightly and flavors meld. Eat cold.

Quick, right? These are textbook Protein Powder Food Recipes — simple to make and satisfying.

---

Pro tips for a perfect cup

• Use cold dairy (or dairy alternative) for the thickest custard.
• Add milk slowly — too much and it gets runny. Start small.
• Whisk like you mean it to eliminate lumps from protein powder. A small immersion blender works wonders.
• Choose ripe-but-not-spotted bananas so slices stay firm and pretty.
• If you want extra sweetness, use a pinch of stevia rather than extra powder — it won’t mess with texture.
• Make ahead: assemble without the banana slices if you plan to store longer; add fresh bananas just before serving so they don’t brown.

Bold tip: don’t use overripe bananas unless you want brown mush. Keep them slightly firm.

---

Variations to try

• Swap in coconut yogurt for a dairy-free version — still counts among Easy Healthy Pudding Recipes.
• Use chocolate or peanut butter protein for a twist — hello, PB-banana vibes.
• Crumble high-protein granola instead of wafers for more protein and crunch.
• Layer with berries for a mixed-fruit cup.
• Want a low-carb spin? Use High Key sugar-free wafers and a keto-friendly protein — technically near Sugar Free Banana Desserts territory.

---

Best way to serve

Serve chilled in small jars or ramekins. Garnish with a banana slice and a wafer crumb. These make great Vanilla Protein Dessert Recipes for potlucks or batch meal prep. Pop a spoon in, stash one in your gym bag, or present them as a lighter dessert after dinner.

---

Storage & leftovers

• Refrigerate in airtight containers up to 5–7 days if you omit banana slices in the jar.
• With bananas added, eat within 48 hours for freshness.
• You can freeze the custard (without bananas or wafers) for up to a month — thaw in the fridge and re-whisk.

Quick tip: If the gaggle-of-wafers gets soggy overnight, toss extra crumbs on top right before eating.

---

Who should make these? (and when)

These cups work for athletes, busy parents, or anyone who wants a sweet treat that supports protein goals. They qualify as Soft Foods With Protein, so they’re great for recovery days or when you want something easy to eat. They also answer the question: What are good Things To Add Protein Powder To? — and the answer is: pudding.

---

FAQs

Print