The Best Lobster Tail Recipe — Buttery & Easy

Lobster Tail Recipe — Butter-Garlic Herb Broiled Lobster

This Lobster Tail Recipe turns supermarket lobster into a restaurant-worthy feast: succulent tails brushed with a garlicky herb butter, broiled at high heat until tender and golden. Skip the reservation — you can make an elegant surf-and-turf night at home with minimal fuss and maximal “wow.”

Want to impress your Valentine (or just treat yourself)? Let’s get into it.

---

Brief introduction to the recipe

Butter-Garlic Herb Broiled Lobster feels fancy but behaves like a simple weeknight winner. You butterfly the tail, lift the meat out of the shell, slather it in a seasoned butter, and broil until opaque and slightly browned on top. The whole process takes under 20 minutes from prep to table — yes, really.

Think: restaurant plating without the markup. Fancy? Sure. Complicated? Not at all.

---

Why you’ll love this recipe

• It’s quick — prep + broil in under 20 minutes.
• It’s decadent — rich butter and garlic elevate delicate lobster meat.
• It’s flexible — broil, bake, grill, or poach depending on mood and gear.
• It’s cost-effective — makes splurgy dinners affordable at home when you compare to steakhouses.

Who doesn’t want a gourmet meal that doesn’t demand a culinary degree?

---

The Key Ingredients (and Why You Need Them) to Make This Easy Lobster Tail Recipe

Below I list the core components (no amounts here — the printable card has those). I’ll explain the job each one does so you can tweak with confidence.

• Lobster tails — The star. Choose fresh, firm tails with clean, white-pink meat. Cold-water lobster often tastes sweeter and holds texture better. Avoid tails with off smells or unpleasant discoloration.
• Butter — Fat is flavor. Butter bastes the meat and caramelizes under broil for that golden finish. Use unsalted so you can control seasoning.
• Garlic — Fresh garlic gives punch; roasted garlic gives mellow sweetness. Both are great.
• Fresh herbs (thyme, rosemary, parsley) — Herbs bring brightness and aromatic depth to the butter. Dry herbs work in a pinch, but fresh is ideal.
• Paprika — Adds color and a subtle smoky note.
• Salt & pepper — Season thoughtfully; lobster needs seasoning but not a heavy hand.
• Lemon — Zest and juice brighten the butter and cut rich flavors.

Pro tip: buy high-quality lobster and fresh herbs. The recipe is simple — so ingredient quality shows.

---

How to Make It

This is the step-by-step you actually want — clear, quick, and tested.

1. Preheat your broiler (or oven broil setting). Position the top rack about 4–5 inches from the heating element.
2. Prep the lobster tails. With sharp kitchen shears, cut down the center of the top shell, lengthwise. Flip the tail over, slide fingers under the meat, and gently lift the meat out of the shell, keeping the base attached. Lay the meat on top of the shell for presentation. This is called butterflying.
3. Season the meat. Lightly salt and pepper the exposed meat.
4. Make the garlic-herb butter. Melt butter and whisk with minced garlic, chopped parsley, thyme, a pinch of paprika, and a squeeze of lemon juice. Taste and adjust.
5. Brush liberally. Slather the butter over each lobster tail, making sure the meat gets a good coating. Reserve extra butter for serving.
6. Broil. Place the tray under the broiler and cook until the meat turns opaque and gets a light brown top. Aim for about 1 minute per ounce of tail weight — check early and often. For accuracy, target an internal temperature of 145°F in the thickest part.
7. Finish & serve. Serve immediately with melted butter, lemon wedges, and a sprinkle of chopped parsley.

Bold tip: use a meat thermometer—it tells you when lobster is perfectly done without guesswork.

---

How to Butterfly a Lobster Tail (Simple Method)

Butterflying looks fussy but is easy once you try it.

• Place tail shell-side up and use kitchen shears to cut along the back, down the center of the shell.
• Carefully pry the shell apart just enough to slip your fingers beneath the meat.
• Lift the meat up and over the shell, keeping it attached at the base.
• Rest the meat on top of the shell and close the shell sides around the bottom for a neat presentation.

FYI: if you accidentally nick the meat, no biggie — it will still cook beautifully.

---

How Long to Broil Lobster (Timing Guide)

Broiling time depends on tail size and oven heat. Use these as starting points:

• Small tails (4–6 oz): 6–8 minutes.
• Medium tails (6–8 oz): 7–9 minutes.
• Large tails (8+ oz): 8–12 minutes; move rack lower if needed to avoid scorching.

One-minute-per-ounce is a solid rule of thumb, but monitor closely. Lobster goes from perfect to rubbery quickly.

Bold safety tip: pull at 145°F internal temp. Overcooking is the most common mistake — and the easiest to avoid with a thermometer.

---

Different Ways to Cook Lobster Tails

Variety is the spice of seafood life. Try these alternatives:

• Broiled (this recipe): Fast, caramelized top, classic buttery finish. My go-to.
• Baked: Slightly gentler heat; good for thicker tails or if you prefer even cooking. Bake at 425°F until opaque (Lobster Tail Recipe Baked).
• Poached (butter-poached): Sous-vide vibe without the gear; simmer in butter for a silky texture. Luxury move.
• Boiled: Simple and reliable; you lose some buttery flavor but get consistent cook.
• Grilled: Adds char and smoky notes — great for summer. Brush with butter and grill meat-side down briefly.

Each method produces delicious lobster — pick based on mood and equipment.

---

Pro Tips for the Best Cooked Lobster Meat Recipes

• Buy cold-water lobster when possible. It tastes cleaner and holds a firmer texture.
• Avoid tails treated with sodium tripolyphosphate (STPP). These can yield off-flavors and odd textures.
• Butterfly the tails the day of cooking. Doing it too early risks discoloration.
• Use a thermometer. It’s the difference between tender and rubbery.
• Don’t skip the herb butter. It’s the flavor kicker that transforms simple lobster into a special-occasion dish.
• Adjust oven rack for size. For giant tails move the rack down an inch to prevent scorching.

Bold reminder: don’t overcook. Lobster should be tender and juicy, not tough.

---

Variations to Try

• Garlic-Parmesan lobster: Mix grated Parm into the butter for a salty, umami kick.
• Spicy chili butter: Add red pepper flakes or a dash of cayenne for heat.
• Citrus-herb: Use lemon and orange zest in your butter for a bright twist.
• Old Bay butter: Stir in Old Bay seasoning for a classic seafood profile.
• Surf & Turf: Pair with a garlic butter steak for a stunning dual-protein plate.

Small tweaks add big personality. Feeling bold? Toss in truffle oil for a luxe finish.

---

Best Ways to Serve

• Simple & classic: Lobster, lemon wedges, melted butter, parsley. Done.
• Surf & turf: Serve alongside a perfectly seared ribeye or filet for major date-night energy.
• With sides that sing: Garlic herb mashed potatoes, roasted asparagus, or parmesan roasted cauliflower pair beautifully.
• For a crowd: Serve family-style on a platter with citrus and herb garnish.

Presentation tip: fan the shells and place the tails on a bed of coarse salt or lemon halves for a restaurant look.

---

Quick Tips for Storage & Leftovers

• Serve immediately. Lobster tastes best fresh from the oven.
• Short-term storage: Refrigerate cooked lobster in an airtight container for up to 2 days. Reheat gently (steaming or low oven) to avoid drying out.
• Avoid reheating in the microwave unless you’re okay with a texture shift.
• Make-ahead mise en place: You can prep herb butter in advance and butterfly tails an hour before service.

FYI: reheated lobster won’t be exactly like fresh, but it still makes excellent salads, pasta, or lobster rolls.

---

FAQs

---

Final thoughts

This Best Lobster Tail Recipe proves that you don’t need a restaurant to pull off a luxurious seafood dinner. With a few pantry staples — butter, garlic, fresh herbs, and high-quality lobster — you can plate something worthy of a special occasion. Broiling concentrates flavor and gives you that gorgeous caramelized top; broil carefully and you’ll be rewarded with tender, juicy lobster every time.

Fancy? Absolutely. Hard? Not even close. So, ready to impress? Grab some lobster tails, melt the butter, and turn dinner into an occasion. One last bold tip: make extra garlic herb butter—you’ll want every last drop.

Follow me on Pinterest for daily new recipes.

Print