Cozy & Creamy Holiday Eggnog Pudding — Make-Ahead Crowd-Pleaser

Holiday Eggnog Pudding — cozy, make-ahead, and utterly dreamy

If you want a show-stopping Holiday Eggnog Pudding that tastes like liquid holiday cheer turned into spoonable velvet, this recipe is your new obsession. It’s silky, spiced, and the perfect way to use up extra eggnog—or to justify buying a few extra cartons.

Brief introduction to the recipe

This is a from-scratch, no-joke creamy pudding made with real egg yolks, cornstarch, cream, and of course, eggnog. It sets up dense and custardy, not thin and sad, and it plays beautifully with whipped cream, sugared cranberries, or a sprinkle of freshly grated nutmeg. Make it ahead, chill it, and watch it become the dessert everyone fights over.

Why you’ll love this recipe

• Ridiculously creamy texture. This isn’t instant pudding — it’s thick, rich, and spoonable like a proper Homemade Pudding should be.
• True eggnog flavor. If you love eggnog, you’ll adore the full-flavored Eggnog Dessert vibe here—rum notes, nutmeg, and that vanilla-cream base.
• Make-ahead magic. Prep in 15 minutes, chill overnight, and you’re set for parties. Perfect for when life gets busy.
• Versatile serving options. Serve in ramekins, layer into parfaits, or use as a filling for tartlets or cookie cups.
• Crowd-pleaser. This works as an intimate spoon dessert or scaled up as a Eggnog Pudding Recipe for gatherings.

The story behind this pudding

One holiday season I bought eggnog on impulse because it was on sale. I drank a few cups… then realized I needed more ways to enjoy it than just the carton. After a few experiments—tweaking cornstarch, egg yolk ratios, and a touch of rum extract—I landed on this version. It tastes like a richer, spoonable eggnog: all charm, no awkward mouthfeel. The first time I tested it with friends, someone literally said, “This is the best pudding ever.” I took that as a win.

Ingredients breakdown (short blurbs)

• Eggnog: The star. Swap the milk/cream combo for eggnog and you get instant holiday character. Use store-bought or Homemade Eggnog if you’re feeling ambitious.
• Heavy cream: Adds body and silk—don’t skimp.
• Granulated sugar: Balances the spices and lifts the dairy.
• Cornstarch: The engine that turns liquid into pudding. Whisk it well to avoid lumps.
• Ground nutmeg: Essential. Grate fresh if you can for the brightest flavor.
• Egg yolks: Give richness and that velvet custard texture everyone loves.
• Rum extract (or a splash of rum): Heightens the eggnog profile—use extract for a kid-friendly version if you prefer.
• Unsalted butter: Stirred in at the end for glossy finish and extra silk.

Ingredients (quick list)

• 3 cups eggnog (store-bought or Homemade Eggnog)
• 1 cup heavy cream
• 1/2 cup granulated sugar
• 3 tablespoons cornstarch
• 1/4 teaspoon salt
• 1 teaspoon ground nutmeg (plus extra for garnish)
• 3 large egg yolks
• 2 teaspoons rum extract or 1 tablespoon rum
• 2 tablespoons unsalted butter, cut into pieces

How to Make It — step-by-step

This is the classic stovetop-custard method—easy and reliable.

1. Mix the dry: In a medium saucepan, whisk together sugar, cornstarch, salt, and nutmeg until uniform. This helps the cornstarch distribute evenly.
2. Beat the yolks: Add the egg yolks to the dry mix and whisk until you form a smooth paste. Keep whisking—don’t panic if it looks odd at first.
3. Combine liquids: In a measuring cup, mix eggnog and heavy cream. Pour this slowly into the yolk mixture while whisking constantly to avoid scrambling.
4. Cook gently: Heat over medium, stirring continuously. The mixture will thicken—watch closely. Once it reaches a gentle boil, continue to cook for 30 more seconds to activate the cornstarch fully. This step prevents grittiness.
5. Finish with butter and rum: Remove from heat and stir in the butter and rum extract until glossy and combined.
6. Strain: Pour through a fine-mesh sieve into a clean bowl to catch any cooked bits. This gives a laser-smooth pudding.
7. Chill: Press plastic wrap directly onto the surface to prevent a skin, then chill at least 4 hours or overnight. The texture firms and the flavor deepens.

Pro tip: If the pudding looks a touch lumpy, the sieve fixes that instantly. Always strain for silky results.

Pro tips for perfect results

• Whisk constantly while heating—no exceptions. This avoids curdled eggs.
• Cook the pudding until it bubbles for 30 seconds; cornstarch needs that to fully thicken without gritty texture.
• Press plastic wrap onto the surface as soon as it cools. This stops a skin from forming.
• Taste and adjust after chilling. If you want more spice, add a pinch of nutmeg right before serving.
• Use a thermometer: aim for about 175–180°F before the short boil. Don’t scorch it.
• Chill long enough. Overnight gives the best set and flavor meld.

Variations to try

• Mini custard cheesecakes: Fold some whipped mascarpone into cooled pudding and spoon into gingersnap-lined mini tart shells for a riff on Mini Eggnog Cheesecake With Gingersnap Crust. Fancy, right?
• Boozy boost: Swap rum extract for real rum (1 Tbsp). Adults-only crowd? Go bold.
• Non-alcoholic: Use extra vanilla and a drop more nutmeg to mimic the spirit without booze.
• Caramel eggnog pudding: Swirl salted caramel into the cooled pudding for a richer dessert.
• Mini Eggnog Cheesecake Recipe crossover: Use this pudding as a cheesecake base—layer into small jars with graham crumbs for a hybrid dessert.

Best ways to serve

• Simple and classic: Top with whipped cream and freshly grated nutmeg. Clean, gorgeous, and always loved.
• Festive sparkle: Add sugared cranberries or a gingersnap crumble for texture and holiday flair.
• Parfait style: Layer pudding with crushed gingersnaps, whipped cream, and a drizzle of warm caramel.
• As a filling: Use in cream puffs, doughnut holes, or cookie cups for a pastry-worthy treat.
• Party shots: Spoon into small cups and top with whipped cream for Mini Eggnog Cheesecake Recipe–style bites. Perfect for grazing tables.

Quick tips for storage and leftovers

• Refrigerate in an airtight container up to 4 days. It keeps its texture nicely.
• Freeze? I don’t recommend freezing this pudding—thawing can disrupt the silky texture. Make fresh when possible.
• Re-whip the top: If the surface loses some loft, stir gently before serving to revive creaminess.
• Make-ahead: You can prep the pudding a day or two in advance—ideal for holiday hosting.

FAQs

Fun serving ideas & pairings

• Pair with espresso or a dark roast coffee—balances sweetness nicely.
• Serve alongside spiced cookies or biscotti for textural contrast.
• Add a small shot glass of Baileys on the side for curious guests—let them spike as they please (FYI: this is dangerous but delicious).
• For New Year’s or holiday brunch, offer pudding with mini waffles or pancakes for a decadent spin.

Variations that riff on classics

• Eggnog Frangipane: Fold pudding into almond frangipane for a nutty tart.
• Mini Eggnog Cheesecake With Gingersnap Crust: Press gingersnaps into mini tins, fill with slightly thickened pudding, chill, and serve. You’ll get crowd applause.
• Festive Eggnog Dessert trifles: Layer with spiced cake, whipped cream, and toasted pecans.

Troubleshooting

• Grainy texture: You didn’t cook the cornstarch long enough. Heat to a boil for 30–45 seconds and strain.
• Too thin: You may not have cooked long enough or you under-measured cornstarch. Whisk cornstarch with sugar first, or whisk a slurry and reheat gently.
• Curdled eggs: You heated too fast. Whisk constantly and cook over medium, not high.

Final thoughts — wrap-up

This Holiday Eggnog Pudding turns simple ingredients into luxurious dessert joy. It’s ideal for holiday trays, intimate dinners, or anytime you crave a rich, nostalgic treat. Make it your own with gingersnaps, sugared cranberries, or a boozy splash.

Want to experiment further? Try converting it into a Homemade Eggnog Custard tart, or use it as a base for a Mini Eggnog Cheesecake Recipe—both win on presentation and flavor. IMO, the small tweaks make it feel seasonal and special without extra fuss.

So—are you ready to stir, chill, and spoon your way to pudding glory? Make a batch, put on some holiday music, and enjoy. If you try the recipe, tell me: did you go classic with whipped cream or get wild with gingersnap crumbs? I want to hear all about it.

Follow me on Pinterest for daily new recipes.

Print