Irresistible Pumpkin Cookie Pie — Fun Thanksgiving Desserts

Irresistible Pumpkin Cookie Pie — yes, start with that sentence. Imagine a giant, soft pumpkin cookie baked right in a pie plate, drizzled with warm spice glaze and cheating pumpkin-pie haters into loving fall. That’s the whole vibe here: pumpkin meets cookie, pie plate meets crowd-pleasing comfort, and nobody has to argue about crust. Sound like your kind of holiday chaos? Good. Let’s bake one.

Why you’ll love this recipe

This isn’t your grandma’s pumpkin pie (no offense, grandma). It’s a giant cookie that behaves like a pie: sliceable, shareable, and gloriously forgiving. If you love Fun Thanksgiving Desserts that don’t require pastry acrobatics, this one’s for you. It’s also perfect when you want a dessert that looks fancy but is almost embarrassingly simple to make.

Bold tip: Use a good cookie mix or a solid homemade pumpkin cookie base — either route gives you predictable results. No one likes raw-center anxiety at dessert time.

The story behind the pie

A friend once brought a “cookie pie” to a potluck and people kept asking for the recipe like it was witchcraft. The idea for the Pumpkin Cookie Pie is almost the same: take everything people love about pumpkin cookies and bake it big. Bonus: you can make it with or without a pie crust. Feeling traditional? Use crust. Want more chew and less fuss? Skip it. Either way, it manages to be nostalgic and new at the same time — a perfect Fall Baking Recipes flex.

Ingredients breakdown (with short blurbs)

• Pumpkin cookie mix (store-bought box or a homemade mix): The base. Follow package directions if you’re using a mix; swap for my quick homemade option if you want total control.
• Unsalted butter (about ½ cup, softened): Adds richness and helps the cookie spread just enough.
• 1 large egg: Binder and lift.
• Pumpkin purée (optional, if you’re making from scratch): A spoonful or two can deepen pumpkin flavor if desired.
• White chocolate chips (1 cup): Sweet pockets that pair surprisingly well with pumpkin spice.
• Chopped pecans (½ cup): For crunch — optional but recommended.
• All-butter pie crust (optional): For the people who want a pie personality.
• Glaze: Powdered sugar + milk + a pinch of pumpkin spice (pumpkin pie spice, cinnamon, or both).

If you want to make this fully homemade, swap the box mix for a simple pumpkin-cookie batter: flour, brown sugar, baking soda, pumpkin spice, a little pumpkin purée, butter, and an egg. Easy peasy.

How to make it — step-by-step “How to Make It”

1. Preheat the oven to 350°F (175°C). Grease a 9-inch pie plate or fit an all-butter crust into it if using.
2. In a large bowl, combine one box of pumpkin cookie mix (or your homemade cookie batter), ½ cup softened unsalted butter, and 1 large egg. If your mix calls for oil or water, use the directions on the package instead — some mixes vary. Stir until the dough comes together.
3. Fold in 1 cup white chocolate chips and ½ cup chopped pecans (or your preferred mix-ins — more on variations below).
4. Press the dough evenly into your prepared pie plate (or into the crust if you used one). Smooth the top with a spatula.
5. Bake 18–25 minutes, until the surface looks set and a toothpick inserted near the center comes out with a few moist crumbs (not raw batter). If you used a crust, check the bottom edges to ensure crust doneness.
6. While the cookie pie rests, whisk together glaze: 1 cup powdered sugar, 2–3 tablespoons milk (adjust for desired thickness), and ½ teaspoon pumpkin pie spice. Drizzle over slightly-warm pie.
7. Let cool enough to slice into wedges. Serve with whipped cream or a scoop of vanilla ice cream for dramatic results.

Quick timing note: Oven temps vary. Start checking at 18 minutes. Slightly underdone = more gooey, slightly overbaked = crispier. Both are valid choices.

Pro tips for perfect results

• Use room-temperature ingredients — your dough will mix more evenly and bake more consistently.
• Don’t over-press the dough into the pie plate. Press evenly but don’t compact it; a little loft makes the texture better.
• If you want cookie edges: Bake on a baking sheet to encourage crisper outside edges. Keep an eye — edges brown faster than center.
• If using a crust: Blind-bake the crust for 7–8 minutes to avoid a soggy bottom, especially if your batter is wetter (from added pumpkin).
• Glaze consistency: Use less milk for a thicker glaze; use heavy cream for a richer drizzle.
• Make-ahead: Bake the cookie pie, cool completely, then wrap and store at room temp for up to 2 days. Rewarm briefly before glazing for that fresh-baked vibe.

Variations to try (because variety is the spice of life)

• Pumpkin Pie With Cookie Crust: Flip it — use a cookie dough crust (graham crumbs or crushed cookies mixed with butter) and fill with pumpkin cookie batter.
• Chocolate-studded: Swap white chocolate for dark or semisweet chips. For ultra-decadence, swirl melted chocolate into the top before baking.
• Nut-free: Leave out the pecans and add extra chocolate or dried cranberries.
• Pumpkin Slab Pie: Make it in a 9×13 pan for bars — perfect for feeding a crowd or turning into portable treats.
• No-bake Turtle Pumpkin Pie: Love turtles (pecans + caramel + chocolate)? Make a no-bake interpretation: press cookie crumbs into a pan, pour cooled pumpkin-cookie-flavored pudding, top with caramel and pecans. (Yep, that’s how No-bake Turtle Pumpkin Pie was born in my imagination.)
• Crustless for cookie lovers: Bake dough directly in the pie plate for a chewy, cookie-first experience — this is the most carefree option.

Best ways to serve

• Slightly warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream is classic and irresistible.
• Drizzle extra caramel or chocolate for Fun Pumpkin Pie Recipes vibes.
• Make it a Thanksgiving centerpiece: garnish with toasted pecans and a light dusting of cinnamon.
• Cut into bars for potlucks, or serve slices with coffee for a brunch twist.

Quick tips for storage and leftovers

• Store covered at room temperature for up to 3 days — the texture is best fresh, but leftovers stay yummy.
• To freeze: cool completely, slice into wedges or wrap whole in plastic, then freeze up to 3 months. Thaw overnight in the fridge and rewarm briefly before glazing.
• Reheat a slice for 10–15 seconds in the microwave for a warm, gooey fix — or 7–10 minutes at 300°F in the oven if you want a crisp edge.

FAQs (fast answers for fast bakers)

Final thoughts — the last bite

If you want Fall Pie Recipes that feel cozy, clever, and very forgiving, the Pumpkin Cookie Pie delivers on all counts. It’s also an excellent test to see which camp your family falls into: pumpkin-pie purists or cookie-first rebels. Either way, it’s party-proof, potluck-ready, and melts into a perfect dessert conversation starter.

Make it with a crust or without. Mix in pecans, white chocolate, or both. Turn it into a Pumpkin Slab Pie for a crowd. However you do it, the goal stays the same: impress with minimal drama and maximum fall flavor.

Go on — try this Easy Peasy Pumpkin Pie hybrid, and let me know if it converts anyone on your guest list. (FYI: it usually does.)

Follow me on Pinterest for daily new recipes.

Print