Award Winning Pies Recipes: Custard Pie with Decadent Praline Sauce

If you’ve ever wondered why Award Winning Pies Recipes always seem to have that one show-stopping dessert that makes the entire table fall silent, this Custard Pie with Praline Sauce is exactly that pie. From its ultra-velvety filling to its buttery oatmeal cookie crust (yep, cookie crust), this beauty checks every box. And because it’s secretly simple, it lands squarely in the category of “why don’t I make this more often?” desserts.

The best part? This isn’t just a custard pie. It’s a creamy dream that becomes next-level outrageous with praline sauce—basically a caramel-pecan situation guaranteed to make people ask if you have another slice hidden somewhere. If you’ve been searching for a Pecan Custard Pie Recipe, a nostalgic dessert with a twist, or one of those Custard Pies Recipes that never fail, you’re in for a treat.

Let’s dive in—because this pie deserves a proper introduction.

---

A Cozy, Creamy Dessert That Feels Like a Warm Hug

This custard pie works hard behind the scenes to deliver maximum comfort with minimal fuss. It blends the simplicity of old-fashioned baking with just enough flair to make you feel like you’ve pulled off something impressive (because you have). The filling melts on the tongue, the spices add a warm glow, and the crust—an easy oatmeal cookie crust—refuses to go soggy on you. Honestly, it’s like the universe finally agreed that dessert deserves to be this easy.

And if you’re the type who gets weak in the knees for caramel and pecans? Add that praline drizzle and enjoy a dessert that rivals any Praline Pie Recipe you’ve ever tried.

---

Why You’ll Love This Custard Pie (Seriously, You Will)

Think you already know custard pie? Think again. This version hits differently:

• The praline sauce is outrageous. It’s sticky, buttery, nutty, and adds crunch to the silkiness of the pie. In other words, perfection.

• The texture is flawless. Thanks to scalded milk, balanced ingredients, and low-and-slow baking, the filling becomes silky rather than rubbery or over-set.

• The cookie crust is genius. No chilling forever. No rolling. No anxiety. Just mix, press, and go.

• The ingredients are everyday staples. Eggs, milk, sugar, vanilla—nothing fancy unless you count the praline sauce, which is fancy in the best way.

• It works for ANY occasion. Holidays, potlucks, family dinners, Tuesdays when you need joy—this pie fits everywhere.

• It’s flexible. Want berries? Do it. Want it plain? Gorgeous. Want a Pecan Pie With Custard Filling-style twist? Add pecans to the custard. Want no crust at all? Okay, that’s chaos, but you do you.

If you love a dependable dessert with a little drama, this pie’s your new best friend.

---

A Little Story Behind This Pie

Every home baker has “that one pie.” The one you pull out when you want people to think you magically gained pastry-chef powers overnight. This was one of those pies for me. The kind that surprises you because it’s so low effort for such high reward.

The first time I tested this recipe, I made the oatmeal cookie crust on a whim because I was tired of fighting with traditional pastry. The result? A crust that stayed crisp, tasted like a giant cookie, and didn’t collapse under custard’s moisture. From there, this pie took on a life of its own.

Then came the praline sauce—born out of my craving for something in the neighborhood of Pecan Custard Pie, but more fun and with more caramel action. And it worked. Big time.

This dessert quickly upgraded itself from “let’s try this” to “this is going in the binder under Do Not Lose This Recipe.”

---

Ingredient Breakdown: Why Each One Matters

The magic of custard pie comes from simple ingredients behaving beautifully together. Here’s the lineup:

Eggs

You’ll use four whole eggs plus one yolk. The yolks add richness while the whites bring structure. This combo gives the pie that perfect middle ground—set enough to slice, silky enough to melt.

Milk

Whole milk is the hero. It creates a delicate but rich base without turning the pie heavy. Lower-fat milk produces a thinner, sadder custard—trust me, go full-fat here.

Heavy Cream

Cream adds body, luxury, and that luscious mouthfeel. You can swap for half-and-half, but cream gives you the real deal (and you’ll need cream anyway for the praline sauce).

Sugar

Sugar sweetens and helps the custard set. It also balances the warm spices so the pie leans cozy rather than bland.

Warm Spices

Nutmeg, cinnamon, and a pinch of cloves create the signature custard-pie warmth. A little goes a long way, so keep it gentle—not pumpkin-pie levels.

Vanilla

Vanilla bean paste or extract both work. Paste brings the fancy speckles. Extract brings familiarity. Either one makes the custard taste like a hug.

Crust Ingredients

Butter, sugar, oats, flour, and salt form that wonderfully crisp cookie crust. It holds up against moisture and keeps its structure like a champ.

Together, these basics create something way beyond basic. It’s the magic of classic Pie Dish Recipes—simple ingredients, spectacular results.

---

How to Make It: Step-by-Step, No Stress Required

1. Make the Cookie Crust

Cream butter and sugar until fluffy. Mix in the egg yolk and vanilla. Add oats, flour, and salt, then water. Press into your pie dish using medium pressure.

Pro Tip: Don’t smash it in like you’re mad at it. A light touch keeps it from cracking later.

Chill for at least 30 minutes.

2. Par-Bake the Crust

Bake at 375°F until lightly golden. This step locks in crispness and keeps your crust from turning soggy when the custard hits it.

3. Scald the Milk and Cream

Heat gently until steaming with tiny bubbles around the edges. Don’t boil! Overheating = scrambled egg disaster.

4. Whisk the Eggs and Sugar

Mix them immediately—no letting them sit together or the sugar will start extracting moisture from the eggs. (Yes, it’s a thing. Sugar burn is real.)

Whisk in the spices and vanilla.

5. Temper the Eggs

Slowly drizzle in the hot milk while whisking. This step prevents curdling and keeps the custard smooth.

6. Strain Into the Crust

Pour through a mesh sieve to ensure nothing grainy sneaks in.

7. Bake Slowly

Bake at 325°F until the center reaches 175°F. The pie should jiggle like set Jell-O in the middle and be firmer at the edges.

Cool at room temp, then chill for several hours.

8. Make the Praline Sauce

Cook pecans, sugar, butter, corn syrup, and spices until glossy and sticky. Add cream and vanilla. Let cool briefly.

This is where your pie goes from “nice” to “hello, did you make this professionally?”

9. Garnish Your Pie

Pour the praline sauce on top, spread as desired, add coarse sugar if you like extra sparkle, and admire your masterpiece.

---

Why Scalding the Milk Matters

Scalded milk gives you:

• A silkier filling
• Better thickening
• Reduced bake time
• A custard that refuses to curdle under pressure

You don’t have to scald, but IMO, you want your custard pie to be smooth—not accidentally omelet-adjacent.

---

How to Know When Your Pie Is Perfectly Done

Custard is dramatic. Overbake it by just a little, and it loses its charm. Here’s how to get it perfect every time:

• Use a thermometer: 175°F in the center.
• Tap test: The edges should look set, the center should shimmy.
• Knife test: It should come out clean—but do this last since overbaked pies can also pass it.

If the whole pie jiggles? Not done.
If nothing jiggles? Overdone.
If the middle does a soft dance? Nailed it.

---

Make It Ahead Like a Pro

Custard pie is excellent for prepping early. Bake it, cool it, chill it. It stays fresh up to three days. The texture actually improves as it sits, and the flavors deepen.

Serve at room temp or slightly chilled—your call.

---

Pro Tips for Foolproof Results

These are the kind of tips that make the difference between “good pie” and “wow, who made this?”

• Don’t pack the crust too tightly.
• Always pre-bake the crust.
• Keep eggs at room temp.
• Don’t boil the milk—just scald.
• Whisk sugar and eggs immediately.
• Temper slowly.
• Don’t overmix.
• Bake gently and use a thermometer.
• Cool gradually and chill fully.

Follow these, and your pie will rival any southern grandma’s.

---

Variations to Try

Want to play around with this recipe? Try these fun spins:

• Maple Custard Pie – Swap part of the sugar for maple syrup.
• Crème Brûlée Pie – Torch a sugar topping after chilling.
• Lemon Custard Pie – Add zest and juice for brightness.
• Coconut Custard Pie – Fold in shredded coconut.
• Pumpkin Custard Pie – Cozy fall vibes with pumpkin and spices.
• Eggnog Pie – Perfect for the holidays: swap milk/cream for eggnog.

Each variation gives a fresh identity while keeping the nostalgia of classic custard.

---

Best Ways to Serve This Pie

This pie is a blank canvas for toppings. Try:

• Fresh berries
• That unbelievably good praline sauce
• Whipped cream
• Chocolate or caramel drizzle
• A dusting of cinnamon or nutmeg
• A scoop of ice cream (go bold—not vanilla!)

Pairing the creamy custard with bold toppings turns a simple dessert into something unforgettable.

---

Quick Tips for Storage & Leftovers

• Store tightly covered in the fridge up to 3 days.
• Don’t freeze—custard doesn’t appreciate cold temps.
• Keep at room temperature before serving for best texture.

---

FAQ Corner

---

Final Thoughts

This custard pie brings together the comfort of classic baking with the irresistible indulgence of praline topping. It stands shoulder-to-shoulder with any Pecan Custard Pie, Pecan Custard Pie Recipe, or even classic Praline Pie contenders. It also fits perfectly into your favorite Single Crust Pie Recipes Desserts collection, proving once again that simple ingredients can deliver bakery-level results.

Whether you dress it up with praline sauce or keep it traditional, this pie deserves a spot in your favorite Pie Dish Recipes. It’s creamy, cozy, crowd-pleasing, and honestly? Pretty close to perfect.

Follow me on Pinterest for daily new recipes.

Print

Award Winning Pies Recipes, Praline Pie Recipe, Pecan Custard Pie Recipe, Pecan Pie With Custard Filling, Custard Pies Recipes, Single Crust Pie Recipes Desserts, Pecan Custard Pie, Praline Pie, Pie Dish Recipes