Cherry Cola Margarita — The Ultimate Summer Sip

The Cherry Cola Margarita blends bright cherry, zippy lime, and fizzy cola into a playful, crowd-pleasing cocktail that’s equal parts nostalgia and summer swagger. It borrows the sweet, almond-y note of an Italian margarita and the simple, refreshing structure of a Batanga — then tops it all off with your favorite cola. Yum, right?

Brief introduction to the recipe

If you want a cocktail that’s fun to make and even more fun to drink, this is it. Fresh cherries get muddled with lime, shaken with amaretto and tequila, then finished with a splash of cola for effervescence. It’s refreshing, slightly boozy, and somehow both retro and modern at the same time. Perfect for backyard hangs, casual date nights, or any time you want something different from the standard margarita.

---

Why you’ll love this drink

• It’s a mash-up of two classics — Italian margarita + Batanga — so you get sweetness, depth, and fizz in one glass.
• Super simple: muddle, shake, strain, top with cola — no complicated syrups or long prep.
• The recipe adapts easily: make it boozy, lighter, or booze-free for guests.
• It’s an approachable Cherry Cocktail Recipe for casual entertaining and a solid entry among Summer Food And Drink Recipes.
• Love a masculine-style pour? The flavor profile works as a Manly Mixed Drink or a surprisingly flirty Alcohol Drinks For Women — depends on who’s holding the shaker.

---

The Key Ingredients (and Why You Need Them)

Below I list the main ingredients (no amounts here — the recipe card has those). I’ll explain what role each plays so you understand how and why to tweak things.

• Cherries — Fresh or thawed frozen cherries give bright, jammy fruit flavor and a touch of natural sweetness. They form the heart of the drink.
• Lime juice — Sharp acidity is essential. It balances the sweetness from the cherries and amaretto so the cocktail tastes lively, not cloying.
• Amaretto — This almond-flavored liqueur replaces an orange liqueur and gives a richer, dessert-like note that plays well with cherry.
• Tequila (blanco or reposado) — The base spirit. Blanco keeps things clean and bright; reposado adds a little oak and warmth. Choose 100% agave for the best taste.
• Cola — The fizzy top-off. Use whichever cola you like — Coke Zero for a lighter finish, or full-sugar cola for maximum nostalgia. Different colas change sweetness and character, so experiment.
• Ice — You’ll use it in the shaker and the glass; coldness is crucial for balance and refreshment.

Why these choices matter: the interplay of cherry, lime, and amaretto gives the cocktail complexity, and the cola adds texture and a fizzy lift. This combo creates a drink that’s both refreshing and layered.

---

Mocktail option (note): Substitute amaretto with Torani amaretto syrup (or omit), and swap tequila for a zero-proof spirit or leave it out. Top with Diet Coke or Coke Zero for a satisfying non-alcoholic version. Bold tip: use zero-proof alternatives or syrup plus cola for a tasty mocktail that still feels special.

---

Pro tips for perfect results

• Muddle carefully. You want juice and a touch of texture, not a bowl of smashed fruit. Muddle until cherries give up their juice and color.
• Fresh lime matters. Always use fresh lime juice — bottled lime tastes flat and can throw the balance off.
• Choose tequila intentionally. Blanco tequila keeps the cocktail bright; use reposado if you want oak and warmth.
• Chill everything. Cold ingredients equal a crisper, cleaner drink. Chill glassware if you can.
• Adjust sweetness with cola choice. Coke Zero or Diet Coke cuts sweetness; full-sugar cola makes it more dessert-like.
• Shake, don’t stir. Shaking adds texture and properly chills the fruit-forward mix before you top with bubbly.
• Serve On The Rocks Drinks right. Use large ice cubes for slower dilution — they keep the drink cold without watering it down quickly.

Bold tip: Taste as you go — if the mix tastes too sweet, add a splash more lime; if it’s too tart, add a little extra amaretto or cola.

---

Variations to try

• Cherry Cola Margarita Pitcher: Scale up muddled cherries, lime, amaretto, and tequila, then top with cola in a pitcher for parties. Add extra lime and adjust cola to taste.
• Smoky twist: Use a reposado or añejo tequila instead of blanco for a smoother, smoky profile.
• Spicy Cherry Cola Margarita: Muddle a slice of jalapeño with the cherries for a kick. Remove seeds for milder heat.
• Cherry-Dr Pepper Remix: Swap cola with Dr Pepper for a bolder, spiced finish.
• Frozen version: Blend the shaken base with ice and top with cola pour-over for a slushy take — fun for hot days.
• Cherry Vanilla: Add a drop of vanilla extract or use vanilla-amaretto syrup for a richer, dessert-forward sipper.

---

Best ways to serve

• Casual patio nights: Serve in short rocks glasses with a lime wheel. These feel refreshingly simple.
• Dinner pairing: This is a playful complement to grilled meats, tacos, or spicy bar snacks — perfect for Summer Food And Drink Recipes spreads.
• Party pitcher: Make a big batch and set out a bowl of cherries and lime wheels so guests can garnish their own.
• Low-key date night: Serve alongside salty snacks (think chips with guac) for an easy, flirtatious evening.

Want to lean into a more masculine presentation? Serve as part of a lineup of Manly Mixed Drinks with charred citrus and a smoked salt rim. Prefer something flirty? Offer it in coupe glasses with a maraschino cherry on a pick — it reads as Alcohol Drinks For Women without stereotyping.

---

Quick tips for storage and leftovers

• Pre-mix the non-carbonated base (muddled cherries + lime + spirits + amaretto) and keep it chilled up to 24 hours. Add cola and ice just before serving.
• Do not premix with cola — the fizz will disappear. Top with cola right before serving for best bubbles.
• Leftover cherries: Use them for garnish, in cocktails, or spoon over ice cream — they’re good stuff.
• Mocktail batches: The syrup option mixes well in advance; just top with soda when serving.

---

FAQs

---

Food pairing ideas

• Tacos al pastor or carne asada — the cola’s caramel notes play nicely with grilled meats.
• Fried chicken sliders — the acidity and fizz cut through richness.
• Charcuterie board — surprising but delicious; cherries echo cured-meat fruitiness.
• Spicy Mexican street corn — the creaminess and spice are a great match with the drink’s brightness.

---

Mocktail & low-ABV options

If you want a non-alcoholic version that still tastes grown-up, try this: muddle cherries and lime, stir in Torani amaretto syrup or almond extract (tiny amount), top with Diet Coke or Coke Zero, and garnish. You’ll get cherry-lime-vanilla vibes without the booze. Bold tip: use a zero-proof spirit if you want complexity without alcohol.

---

Final thoughts — wrap-up

The Cherry Cola Margarita is a delightful mash-up that proves cocktails don’t need to be complicated to be memorable. It’s fizzy, fruity, and effortlessly fun. Whether you lean into its Batanga roots with a splash of cola or emphasize the Italian margarita’s sweetness with amaretto, you end up with a cocktail that’s versatile and crowd-friendly.

Looking for something simple to make that still impresses? This is your winner. Muddle some cherries, shake with tequila and amaretto, top with cola, and cheers — summer in a glass.

Follow me on Pinterest for daily new recipes.

Print