Ultimate Gingerbread Oatmeal Cream Pies — Irresistible Holiday Treat

Why Gingerbread Oatmeal Cream Pies Are the Holiday Must-Bake

Gingerbread Oatmeal Cream Pies are the sandwich-cookie glow-up your holiday cookie tray desperately needs. Picture chewy, slightly crisp-edged oatmeal cookies infused with warm ginger-molasses spice, snagged together with a thick, dreamy vanilla cream middle. Sounds like nostalgia in edible form? Yep — and it’s totally addictive.

Brief introduction to the recipe

This recipe blends classic comfort with a festive twist. Think the sweet, ooey-gooey vibe of packaged oatmeal cream pies, only way better: homemade, full of real spices and molasses, and stuffed with an indulgent buttercream that won’t weep. You get texture, warmth, and that cozy Christmas scent in every bite. Who wouldn’t want that?

Why you’ll love this recipe

Why should you drop everything and bake these now? Because they check a lot of boxes:

• Crunchy edges, pillowy centers — texture heaven.
• Rich ginger-molasses flavor — not flat or fake.
• No cream cheese in the filling — butter-based for stability and classic flavor.
• Freezer-friendly — bake ahead for stress-free hosting.
• Perfect for cookie swaps, neighbor gifts, or a quiet night with cocoa.

Ready to make a batch that’ll make everyone ask for the recipe? Let’s get into the story behind them.

The story behind the recipe

I made these during Cookie Week in 2019 — 36 weeks pregnant with Sidney (OMG — talk about cravings!). I didn’t crave sweets much during pregnancy, but these cookies changed everything. I ripped open a pack of memories — those Little Debbie oatmeal cream pies I loved as a kid — and decided to make a grown-up, holiday-version: Gingerbread Oatmeal Cookies with a luxe cream filling. Tony loved them. I loved them. They practically screamed Christmas. That’s how this obsession was born.

Ingredients breakdown — what each ingredient does

Dry & baking staples

• All-purpose flour — structure. Keeps the cookies tender but stable.
• Rolled oats — chew and nostalgia; do not use steel-cut oats.
• Baking soda — rise and spread control.
• Salt — balances the sweetness and brightens flavors.

Flavor stars

• Dark brown sugar — moisture and depth.
• Blackstrap molasses — the soul of gingerbread; gives that rich, slightly bitter-sweet molasses note.
• Ground ginger, cinnamon, allspice — the warm trio that makes these gingerbread, well, gingerbread.

Fat & binder

• Butter — flavor, mouthfeel, and the reason these cookies taste homemade.
• Egg — binds and gives a bit of lift.

For the filling

• Room-temperature butter — creamy, stable buttercream without cream cheese.
• Powdered sugar — sweetness and body.
• Vanilla extract — brightens the filling.
• A splash of milk — keeps the frosting smooth and pipeable.

Pro tip: Use dark brown sugar and real molasses. Small changes = big flavor differences.

How to make it — step-by-step (short, clear, and fun)

1. Cream the butter and brown sugar. In the bowl of your mixer, beat room-temp butter with dark brown sugar for about 1 minute until fluffy. Add molasses, egg, and vanilla; beat ~1 more minute until glossy.
2. Mix dry ingredients. Whisk together flour, rolled oats, baking soda, ginger, cinnamon, allspice, and salt.
3. Combine. Add dry mix slowly to the wet mix on low speed until just combined. Chill the dough for 1 hour — don’t skip this. Chilling firms the dough so cookies bake with perfect edges and centers.
4. Shape and bake. Preheat oven to 350°F (175°C). Scoop large tablespoon-sized dough balls, roll, and place 2 inches apart on parchment-lined sheets. Bake 9–12 minutes — about 9–10 for soft centers, 12 for crispier edges. Cool 5 minutes on sheet, then transfer to a wire rack. Yields ~30 cookies (15 sandwiches).
5. Make the filling. Beat room-temp butter with powdered sugar, vanilla, and a splash of milk. Start low, then crank to high until smooth and fluffy.
6. Assemble. Spoon or pipe filling onto one cookie leaving a border, top with another cookie, press gently. Let sit at room temp for 1 hour for the filling to set.

Bold tip: Chill the dough. Seriously — it changes everything.

Magical oatmeal cream pie filling — what makes it special

This isn’t your basic frosting. It’s thick, rich, and just a little fudgy — the texture of a true cream pie middle. The extra milk keeps it smooth so it spreads easily, but the butter base keeps it stable. No cream cheese needed. Spoon it, pipe it, or smear it like you mean it.

Want a more nostalgic vibe? Add a pinch of cinnamon to the filling. Want it extra luxe? Stir in a teensy bit of vanilla bean paste.

Pro tips for perfect results

• Use room-temperature butter and egg for even mixing and the right texture.
• Do not overmix once you add flour — mix until just combined. Overworking = tough cookies.
• Roll dough by tablespoons for consistent bake times and cookie size.
• Cool cookies completely before filling to avoid melty messes.
• Let assembled cookies rest 1 hour at room temp for ideal filling firmness.
• For crisp edges, bake longer; for softer centers, pull them early.
• Freeze dough balls on a tray, then bag them — bake from frozen, adding a minute or two to bake time.

Important: Always measure flour properly (spoon into the cup and level off) to avoid dense cookies.

Variations to try (get creative!)

• Spiced maple filling: Swap half the vanilla with maple extract. Yum.
• Chocolate-dipped edges: Dip half of each sandwich into melted chocolate and let set. Fancy.
• Gingerbread latte version: Add instant espresso powder to the filling for a coffee-kick.
• Molasses swap: Use lighter molasses for a milder gingerbread flavor, but dark molasses gives the classic depth.
• Vegan option: Use vegan butter and a flax “egg” (1 tbsp flax + 3 tbsp water, chilled); a reader said it worked — try it and report back!

Best ways to serve

• Plate them with a dusting of powdered sugar for holiday parties.
• Bundle three in a cellophane bag with a ribbon for neighbor gifts — instant hit.
• Pair with hot cocoa, mulled cider, or a strong black coffee.
• Bring to cookie exchanges — they travel well if stacked in a sturdy container.

Quick tips for storage and leftovers

• Room temp: Airtight container for 1–2 days.
• Fridge: Transfer after 1–2 days; they’ll keep 3–4 days chilled.
• Freeze dough: Freeze unbaked dough balls on sheet trays, then bag. Bake from frozen; add a minute or two.
• Freeze assembled sandwiches: Flash freeze assembled cookies on a sheet, then layer with parchment in a sealed bag — thaw on the counter before serving.

Handy tip: Freezing dough gives you an emergency batch of cookies whenever you want — lifesaver during the holidays.

FAQs (short, helpful answers)

A note on nostalgia: the oatmeal cream pie influence

Remember ripping open packaged oatmeal cream pies after school? I do. That neon packet-scent memory inspired these. I wanted the soft chew and the satisfying cream middle, but upgraded — real butter, real spices, and that cozy gingerbread warmth. If you loved those cookies as a kid, these Gingerbread Oatmeal Cookies are your adult-friendly, Christmas-ready answer.

A sprinkle of science (short & nerdy)

• Molasses adds moisture and acidity which reacts with baking soda to help spread and set the cookie texture.
• Brown sugar locks moisture, keeping centers tender.
• Chilling solidifies butter; when it melts in the oven, the cookie spreads more slowly, creating defined edges and soft centers.

Final thoughts — make these now (yes, now)

If you want a cookie that tastes like a Christmas memory with grown-up flavor and texture, Gingerbread Oatmeal Cream Pies deliver in spades. They’re freezer-friendly, gift-friendly, and crowd-pleasing. I mean, who doesn’t want a sandwich cookie that tastes like gingerbread and hugs it with vanilla buttercream? Exactly.

Bake a batch, share with friends, hoard a few in a secret jar — I won’t tell. And if you try a wild variation (hello, espresso filling), drop me a comment and tell me everything. Baking is more fun when you get creative.

Now get your mixer out. Seriously — you’ll thank me (and probably hoard the extras). FYI: these freeze like champs.

Follow me on Pinterest for daily new recipes.

Print

Gingerbread Oatmeal Cream Pies, Gingerbread Oatmeal Cookies Recipe, Oatmeal Pie Gingerbread Man, Gingerbread Oatmeal Cookies, Oatmeal Gingerbread Cookies, Christmas Oatmeal Cream Pie, Gingerbread Cookies With Cream Filling, Gingerbread Oatmeal Creme Pie, Tastes Better From Scratch Gingerbread Cookies