Ultimate Special Christmas Desserts: Eggnog Pudding Recipe with Whipped Cream

Eggnog Pudding Recipe — The Easiest Festive Treat You’ll Make All Season

When the holidays roll around, nothing says cozy like this Eggnog Pudding Recipe — a silky, make-ahead dessert that tastes like the best part of a holiday party in a spoon. It’s sweet, creamy, and crowned with cloud-like whipped cream. Want festive without fuss? You’re about to get it.

Brief introduction to the recipe

This pudding blends classic custard technique with the unmistakable spice-and-cream flavor of eggnog. It sets up firm enough to spoon into little glasses but stays luxuriously silky. Make-ahead friendly? Absolutely — whip it up in minutes and chill until you’re ready to serve. Perfect for last-minute guests or those glorious days of Holiday Meal Planning when you want all the stress to stay out of the kitchen.

Why you’ll love this recipe

• It’s quick to assemble. You can finish the stovetop work in about 10 minutes.
• It’s nostalgic. If you love eggnog, this converts that classic sip into a dessert that both kids and grown-ups adore.
• It’s flexible. Jazz it up with booze for grown-up gatherings or keep it family-friendly.
• It’s crowd-pleasing. This ranks high on the “who’s bringing dessert?” list because it looks cute and tastes even better.

Seriously — how often does a dessert look elegant and actually be simple? This one nails both.

The story behind the pudding

I first made this after finding a carton of extra eggnog in the fridge and zero patience for boxed pudding. I wanted something that tasted like the season without fussing over a giant trifle. One pot, a whisk, and a little patience later, this Eggnog Dessert was born — a tiny holiday miracle that saved more than one tired holiday evening. FYI: the whipped cream is non-negotiable.

Ingredients breakdown (short blurbs)

Here’s what you need and why each ingredient matters:

• Eggnog — The flavor hero. Use good-quality eggnog for real, recognizable spice notes.
• Sugar — Balances the spice and adds that dessert-y sweetness.
• Cornstarch — Thickens the pudding without grit.
• Egg yolks — Give the pudding richness and that golden color.
• Vanilla extract — Heightens the flavors and rounds everything out.
• Heavy cream — For topping — whipped to soft peaks for fluffy contrast.
• Nutmeg — Classic garnish; a little goes a long way.

This is essentially one of the best Pudding Recipes Homemade because it uses pantry staples and turns them into something special.

How to Make It — Step-by-step “How to Cook It”

Follow these steps for smooth, creamy results:

1. Combine dry ingredients. In a heavy-bottomed saucepan whisk sugar, cornstarch, and a pinch of salt until mixed.
2. Whisk in wet ingredients. Slowly add the eggnog and whisk in the egg yolks until the mixture runs smooth.
3. Cook until thick. Set the pan over medium-low heat and stir constantly. After several minutes the mixture will bubble and thicken to a consistency that coats the back of a spoon. That’s your cue to remove it from heat. Stir constantly to avoid lumps.
4. Finish with vanilla. Remove from heat and whisk in vanilla.
5. Chill properly. Press plastic wrap against the surface to prevent a skin. Chill at least 3 hours until set.
6. Whip the cream. Just before serving, beat cold heavy cream with powdered sugar and a touch of vanilla until stiff peaks form. Dollop on each pudding and dust with nutmeg or sprinkle with festive nonpareils.

Quick note: If you want a spiked version, leave out a teaspoon of vanilla in the pudding and add a tablespoon or two of bourbon into the finished pudding before chilling. Boom — adult upgrade.

Pro tips for perfect results

• Use a heavy saucepan to prevent hot spots and burning.
• Whisk constantly while cooking so the cornstarch activates evenly and you end up with a super-smooth texture.
• Press plastic wrap on the surface to stop a skin from forming — nobody likes pudding skin.
• Chill thoroughly; the flavors mellow and the texture firms up best after a few hours.
• If the pudding gets too thick, stir in a splash of eggnog or milk to loosen it before serving.

Bold tip: Always taste the pudding before chilling — a little extra vanilla or a pinch more sugar can make all the difference.

Variations to try

• Boozy eggnog pudding: Stir in bourbon or rum for a grown-up twist.
• Slow-cooker twist: You can adapt the flavors into a Slow Cooker Desserts setup by gently cooking a larger custard base on LOW and stirring occasionally — but watch the texture. Slow-cooker versions need patience and attention.
• Gingerbread swirl: Add a pinch of ginger and molasses to the pudding base to echo your favorite holiday cookie.
• Chocolate eggnog: Fold in melted dark chocolate for a decadent mash-up.
• Citrus brightness: Stir in a touch of orange zest to cut the richness and add a festive note.

Want to keep it simple? Stick to the classic. Want to impress? Add a boozy whisper or a layer of crushed gingersnaps.

Best ways to serve

• In small glasses for pretty individual servings.
• In ramekins with a dusting of nutmeg and a sprig of mint.
• Layered with crushed cookies or gingerbread for texture contrast.
• Serve with shortbread or biscotti for dunking.

This pudding shines as part of a dessert spread of Special Christmas Desserts because it’s easy to prep and looks charming on a platter.

Quick tips for storage and leftovers

• Refrigerate in an airtight container for up to 3 days.
• Re-whip the cream if it loses loft; that fresh whipped texture makes all the difference.
• Freeze? Not recommended — the texture changes.
• Leftover ideas: Use the pudding as a filling for crepes or spread between cake layers for a fun twist on holiday baking.

FAQs

Why this belongs in your holiday lineup

This dessert fits the bill when you want something that tastes special but doesn’t eat your day. It supports smart Holiday Meal Planning since you can make it ahead and store it in the fridge. It also joins the roster of Recipes Using Eggnog that feel seasonal without being fussy. Whether you’re planning a small family dinner or a bigger potluck, this pudding earns its spot.

Final thoughts wrap-up

If you love the smell of nutmeg and the cozy hug of a holiday spice, you need this Eggnog Pudding Recipe in your repertoire. It takes the best parts of classic holiday flavors and turns them into a smooth, spoonable treat. This ranks high among Pudding Recipes Homemade for its simplicity, nostalgia, and flexibility.

So, are you ready to make your holiday table a little merrier and your dessert course a little more memorable? Grab the eggnog, whisk like you mean it, and chill until dessert time. Your friends and family will ask what you did differently this year — smile, shrug, and enjoy the applause. 🎄

Follow me on Pinterest for daily new recipes.

Print