Baked Pumpkin Spice Pudding — Classic Pumpkin Pudding

Pumpkin Pudding is the unsung hero of autumn desserts — all the cozy spice and pumpkin-y comfort of pie, without wrestling a crust or fending off a soggy bottom. Sounds like cheating the classy way, right? Trust me: spooning this out of a casserole dish feels decadent and perfectly justified.

Introduction — why you’ll love this easy swap for pie

Look: pie has its moments. But sometimes you want a dessert that’s foolproof, creamy, and downright comforting. That’s where this Baked Pumpkin pudding steps in. It takes the pumpkin-pie flavor you crave — cinnamon, nutmeg, a whisper of clove — and turns it into a silky, set custard that’s faster, more forgiving, and way easier to transport to the Thanksgiving table. Add a cloud of whipped cream and you’ve got a crowd-pleaser that might appear at breakfast the next day. No judgment here.

What makes this pudding so irresistible?

Why does a tray of pudding beat a pie? For starters, texture. This isn’t runny; it’s luxuriously smooth, with a firm-but-tender set that melts on your tongue. Then there’s the flavor — concentrated pumpkin, warm spices, and a buttery finish — all concentrated in each spoonful. Also, Puddings like this play nicely with toppings: toasted pecans, a drizzle of molasses, or a sprinkle of brown sugar quick-broiled to a crackly finish. Basically, it’s dessert comfort turned professional.

Ingredients — short descriptions so you know what each does

• Pumpkin puree — the base: earthy, silky, and seasonal. Fresh or canned works; drain fresh if it’s watery.
• Whole milk (or half-and-half) — gives the pudding its creamy body. Use half-and-half for extra richness.
• Eggs — the setting agents; they transform the mix into a sliceable custard.
• Sugar — balances pumpkin’s earthiness and plays with the spices. Brown sugar—hello, caramel notes—works beautifully.
• Spices (cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, optional clove) — this is where the “pumpkin pie” vibe lives.
• Vanilla extract — softens and rounds out the spices.
• Salt — tiny but vital for lifting the flavors.
• Optional add-ins: bourbon, maple syrup, or a swirl of caramel for grown-up vibes.

How to make it — simple, no-fuss method

1. Preheat oven to 325°F (165°C). Grease a medium casserole dish.
2. Whisk together pumpkin puree, sugar, spices, salt, and vanilla until smooth.
3. Whisk eggs in a separate bowl, then slowly stream in milk while whisking to combine. Tempering keeps the eggs from scrambling.
4. Mix the egg-milk mixture into the pumpkin until uniform. Pour into the prepared dish.
5. Bake in a water bath (optional but recommended for ultra-silky texture): place the casserole in a larger pan and add hot water halfway up the sides. Bake ~45–60 minutes, until the center barely jiggles.
6. Cool to room temp, chill for at least 2 hours to finish setting. Serve with whipped cream and a dusting of cinnamon.

The story behind this pudding

I found this pudding while leafing through an old cookbook — one of those culinary classics with recipes that feel like family heirlooms. The recipe felt like a revelation: all the nostalgia of pumpkin pie minus the fiddly crust. Over time it became my cheat-day centerpiece: easy to scale, a relief when hosting, and a delight for the picky eater who “doesn’t like pie.” (She always eats two helpings. I caught her.)

Pro tips for the best outcome

Use the water bath for the creamiest, custard-like texture — it prevents edges from overcooking.
Don’t overbake. Remove while the center still wobbles a bit; carryover heat finishes it.
Cool completely before slicing. This helps the pudding set cleanly.
Bold tip: if you want a firmer slice, increase the eggs by one or reduce the milk a bit. That will give you a denser, more trifle-friendly layer.
If you want ultra-rich, swap some milk for heavy cream. If you prefer lighter, use whole milk — still delicious.

Variations to try — riff and make it yours

• Maple Bourbon Pumpkin Pudding: stir 2 tbsp maple syrup and 1–2 tbsp bourbon into the mix.
• Gingered Pumpkin: add extra ground ginger and a pinch of allspice for a brighter, warming edge.
• Coconut Twist: use coconut milk for a dairy-free, tropical nuance.
• Nutty Top: sprinkle chopped toasted pecans or walnuts and broil briefly until toasty.
  Want to make a layered dessert? Use chilled pudding as a base in a Trifle with ginger snaps and whipped mascarpone.

Best ways to serve — casual to fancy

Spoon it warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream for cozy evenings. Chill it and slice for tidy portions at a holiday buffet. For a showstopper, layer the pudding into a trifle bowl with crumbled ginger cookies and spiced whipped cream. If you’d rather Eat Dessert for breakfast (no shame), a small bowl of this with granola makes a decadent morning treat.

Quick tips for storage and leftovers

• Refrigerate covered up to 4 days. It keeps flavor and texture beautifully.
• Freeze? You can—freeze in airtight containers up to 2 months, but thaw slowly in the fridge. The texture softens slightly after freezing, so I prefer fresh or chilled.
  Bold tip: cover the surface with plastic wrap pressed directly on the pudding before chilling to prevent a skin from forming.

FAQs — fast answers to common questions

Why this belongs on your holiday table (and beyond)

This pudding makes entertaining easier: bake it ahead, chill it, and free up oven space for savory mains. It’s forgiving with timing and scales neatly for big crowds. Unlike pie, nobody worries about slicing a perfect wedge — everyone just digs in. If you want to offer a nostalgic Pumpkin Dessert without fuss, this is your new go-to.

Final thoughts — dessert that feels like home

If you want a dessert that’s rooted in tradition but liberated from pastry drama, Pumpkin Pudding delivers. It gives you all the familiar pumpkin-spice warmth and a silky, spoonable joy that’s equally at home on Thanksgiving and on a quiet weekday night. Fold in a bit of personality — toasted nuts, a splash of bourbon, or a crunchy caramel topping — and you’ve got something both classic and personal.

So next time you consider pie, consider this: easier prep, fewer nerves, and every bit as tasty. Bake it, chill it, dollop it with cream, and watch the comfort spread. After all, dessert should be the easiest part of the meal — and the most memorable. Ready to try a slice?

Follow me on Pinterest for daily new recipes.

Print