Keto Copycat Lofthouse Cookies — a Low Carb Cookies with pillowy frosting

Low Carb Cookies stole my heart the first time I bit into a soft, sugar-free Lofthouse-style cookie that didn’t taste like cardboard — pillowy, festive, and shockingly guilt-free.

Low Carb Cookies — introduction

If you miss those nostalgic, frosted sugar cookies but want to stay low-carb, this Keto Copycat Lofthouse recipe is your jam. It gives you the classic thick, soft base and the dreamy, buttery frosting — without the carb crash. These cookies clock in at about 2g net carbs each (depending on your sweetener), so they’re perfect for holiday trays, birthday parties, or a very merry cookie swap where everyone wins.

What makes these cookies irresistible?

Texture wins here. The original Lofthouse cookie is famous for being pillowy and slightly cakey — not thin, not crunchy. This keto version uses almond and a touch of coconut flour to mimic that soft crumb while keeping carbs low. The frosting matters too: skip the gritty powdered erythritol and opt for a Best Keto Sweetener For Baking Cookies (I’ll explain options below) so the frosting stays glossy and silky. Add a pop of color, some sprinkles, and you’ve recreated that childhood vibe — but healthier.

Ingredients (short descriptions)

• Blanched almond flour — the main low-carb flour; fine texture and mild flavor.
• Coconut flour (small amount) — soaks up moisture and prevents collapse; use sparingly.
• Powdered keto sweetener — blends into batters and frostings for that smooth finish.
• Baking powder — lifts the cookie; don’t skip it.
• Salt — enhances flavor and keeps sweetness from tasting flat.
• Unsalted butter — richness and mouthfeel; room temp is best.
• Eggs — structure and tenderness.
• Vanilla extract — rounds the flavor; almond extract is an optional twist.
• For the frosting: butter, powdered sweetener, a splash of heavy cream (or dairy-free creamer), and natural food coloring if you want the classic pastel hues.

Simple method — how to make them

1. Preheat oven to 350°F and line a baking sheet with parchment.
2. Whisk dry ingredients: almond flour, a spoonful of coconut flour, powdered sweetener, baking powder, and a pinch of salt.
3. Beat the butter until fluffy, add eggs and vanilla, then fold in the dry mix. Let the dough rest 5–10 minutes so the coconut flour hydrates.
4. Roll into even balls (about 12), place spaced on the tray, and gently press each into a slightly flattened disk.
5. Bake 8–10 minutes — watch closely. They should look set but not browned. Cool completely.
6. Make frosting: beat butter, sifted powdered sweetener, cream, and a touch of vanilla until silky. Tint with natural colors if you like. Frost generously. Decorate and enjoy.

The story behind this keto copycat

I wanted a cookie that would thrill nostalgic eaters and satisfy keto folks. Testing revealed two truths: powdered sweetener makes the frosting smooth, and coconut flour in tiny amounts prevents sogginess without making the cookie gritty. The result? A faithful copycat Lofthouse vibe that freezes beautifully and decorates like a dream — ideal for Keto Christmas Cookies or year-round celebrations.

Pro tips for bakery-level results

• Chill the dough if it feels too sticky — 15 minutes in the fridge makes shaping easier.
• Don’t overbake. These cookies set quickly; underbake slightly for maximum softness.
• Sift powdered sweetener before making frosting to avoid grit. This is essential if you want frosting that looks and behaves like classic Lofthouse frosting.
• Use room-temp eggs & butter for better emulsion and loft.
• Use a candy thermometer for the frosting if you make a meringue-based or cooked-sweetener version — precise temps = perfect texture.
  Bold tip: If your frosting weeps, chill it for a bit — it’ll firm up and pipe beautifully.

Sweetener choices — picking the Best Keto Sweetener For Baking Cookies

Not all sweeteners behave the same. For powdered-like results, use one of these:

• Erythritol + Monk Fruit (powdered): widely available and bakes well with minimal cooling after baking.
• Allulose (powdered): browns a bit and tastes very close to sugar; great in frostings but pricier.
• Xylitol: behaves well but toxic to pets — avoid if you have dogs.
  For frosting, powdered blends (pre-sifted or homemade powdered erythritol) give the smoothest finish. Try small batches to find your fave.

Variations & riffs

• Keto Frosted Animal Cookies — use animal-shaped silicone molds to make breakfast-friendly shapes (kids love these). Boldly decorate with natural sprinkles.
• Chocolate twist — add a tablespoon of cocoa to the dry mix for chocolate Lofthouse cookies.
• Filled versions — make a small well in the center and pipe a sugar-free jam or chocolate ganache for Filled Cookies vibes.
• Mini sandwich cookies — pipe a thicker frosting and sandwich two cookies together. Great for gifts.
• Gingerbread holiday — add a dash of molasses extract and spices for seasonal flavor while keeping low-carb.

(Include the phrase Keto Frosted Animal Cookies bolded above when mentioning that variation.)

Best ways to serve

Serve these cookies at room temperature for the softest bite. They pair well with unsweetened coffee, black tea, or a cup of bulletproof coffee for a keto-friendly combo. For parties, arrange them on a tiered tray or individually bag them with a ribbon for gifts. Want to impress? dust the frosting with freeze-dried berry powder for a bakery-style finish.

Storage, freezing & reheating — quick hacks

• Room temp: Keep frosted cookies in an airtight container for up to 3 days.
• Fridge: Store for up to a week; bring to room temp before serving for best texture.
• Freeze: Freeze unfrosted cookies in a single layer, then transfer to a bag. Frost after thawing. You can freeze frosted cookies too, but frosting texture can shift slightly.
  Quick reheat: Warm a chilled cookie for 8–10 seconds in the microwave to take the chill off, but don’t overdo it — the frosting can melt.

Low-effort swaps and how they affect the recipe

• No powdered sweetener? Don’t swap granulated; it makes frostings gritty. If you must, blitz your granulated sweetener into a powder first.
• Dairy-free: Use plant-based butter and a dairy-free creamer; texture changes but still tasty.
• Nut-free: Make almond flour-free cookies by using sunflower seed flour — but note the color may darken slightly over time due to chlorogenic acid (it’s still edible though).

Who should make these? (and when)

• Bakers who miss classic frosted cookies but want to stay low-carb.
• Hosts making Keto Christmas Cookies for mixed-diet parties — they pass as “regular” cookies to most folks.
• Anyone looking for Carb Quick Cookies — they’re fast to mix and bake.
• Families who want bright, decorated cookies that don’t spike blood sugar.

FAQs — quick answers you’ll want

Final thoughts — why these belong in your recipe box

If you crave nostalgia but want to keep carbs low, these Keto Copycat Lofthouse cookies deliver big. They look party-ready, taste indulgent, and freeze well for holiday prep. Whether you need Keto Cookie Recipes for a celebration or just want Low Carb Sweets to satisfy a late-night craving, this recipe gives you the fluffy texture and dreamy frosting you remember — without the sugar guilt.

Before you go: want a printable card, a sheet of freezer instructions, or a tiny video script for decorating? I’ll whip one up — because cookies this good deserve a spotlight.

Print